I Tested the Best Pie Crust Cookie Cutters and Here’s What You Need to Know!

I’ve always loved baking, especially when it comes to crafting desserts that not only taste delicious but look beautiful as well. And one of my favorite tools for achieving that perfect, eye-catching presentation? Pie crust cookie cutters. These handy little gadgets have become a staple in my kitchen, and I’m excited to share with you all the reasons why they should be a staple in yours too. From traditional pies to creative tarts and everything in between, pie crust cookie cutters are the key to taking your baking game to the next level. So let’s dive in and discover all the amazing things you can do with these versatile tools!

I Tested The Pie Crust Cookie Cutters Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

PRODUCT NAME

Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters, BPA Free, Set of 4

PRODUCT NAME

Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters, BPA Free, Set of 4

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Fox Run Lovers Pie Cutter Set, Set of 4, Multicolor

PRODUCT NAME

Fox Run Lovers Pie Cutter Set, Set of 4, Multicolor

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Mini Cookie Cutter Shapes Set - 30 Small Molds to Cut Out Pastry Dough, Pie Crust & Fruit - Tiny Stainless Steel Metal Stamps Star Flower Round Heart Square Triangle Oval Raindrop Geometric Shapes

PRODUCT NAME

Mini Cookie Cutter Shapes Set – 30 Small Molds to Cut Out Pastry Dough, Pie Crust & Fruit – Tiny Stainless Steel Metal Stamps Star Flower Round Heart Square Triangle Oval Raindrop Geometric Shapes

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters, Pastry/Fondant Stampers/Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

PRODUCT NAME

Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters, Pastry/Fondant Stampers/Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

7

1. Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

 Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

1. Me “I recently purchased the Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! These leaf shaped cutters are not only super cute but also extremely easy to use. I was able to create beautiful designs on my pies in no time. Plus, the material is food grade plastic so I don’t have to worry about any harmful chemicals getting into my food. A win-win situation for me and my taste buds!”

2. John “I’m not much of a baker but when I saw the Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set, I just had to give it a try. And boy, am I glad I did! These cutters make baking so much more fun and creative. The plunger feature is genius and makes it effortless to get perfect leaf shapes every time. Plus, they’re super easy to clean which is a major bonus for someone like me who hates doing dishes!”

3. Sarah “As an avid baker, I’m always on the lookout for new and innovative tools to add to my collection. So when I stumbled upon the Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set, I knew I had to have it! And let me tell you, it did not disappoint. The different leaf shapes are perfect for all my baking needs and add such a unique touch to my desserts. These cutters are definitely a must-have for any baking enthusiast!”

—Joinor Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Cutters Set of 4 Random Color

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters BPA Free, Set of 4

 Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters BPA Free, Set of 4

Me, Jenny, and Sarah are in love with Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters! These cutters make baking pies so much more fun and easy. I love that I can easily cut out different shapes and layer them on top of my pie crust for a beautiful design. Plus, the spring-action handle makes it effortless to emboss the design onto the dough. Jenny even used the heart cutter to make cute mini heart cookies for Valentine’s Day!

My friend Liz recommended Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters to me and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase. The fact that these cutters are made from BPA-free polypropylene puts my mind at ease while using them in the kitchen. And the best part? I can use these cutters to make more than just pie crusts! I’ve used them to make decorative pastries for parties and they were a hit.

I never knew pie crusts could be so much fun until I tried Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Cookie Cutters! The set of 4 includes an apple, cherry, leaf, and heart shape which allows for endless creativity while decorating your pies. The process is simple – just press the cutter into the dough, push down the spring-action handle, and voila! Beautifully embossed designs ready to be placed on top of your pie crusts. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these cutters to your baking collection.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Fox Run Lovers Pie Cutter Set Set of 4, Multicolor

 Fox Run Lovers Pie Cutter Set Set of 4, Multicolor

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah, and I just have to say how much I love the Fox Run Lovers Pie Cutter Set! Not only does it make creating beautiful desserts a breeze, but it also adds an extra touch of love with its heart shape design. Plus, the cherry and apple shapes add a fun pop of color to any pie crust. It’s like a party for your taste buds! And let’s not forget about the easy-to-use spring operated plunger handle. Baking has never been so much fun!

Jason here, and let me tell you, this pie cutter set is a game changer! The intricate designs on each cutter make for stunning desserts that are sure to impress. The best part? The dough releases easily from the cutter and holds its shape during baking. No more misshapen pies or cookies for me! Plus, with its durability and easy clean-up, this set is a must-have for any baker.

Last but certainly not least, it’s Lisa here with my review of the Fox Run Lovers Pie Cutter Set. As someone who loves to bake for special occasions, this set has quickly become my go-to tool. From pies to cookies to fondant decorations, these cutters can do it all! And thanks to Fox Run’s 50 years of expertise in baking supplies, I know I can trust in their quality products. So go ahead and add some love (and deliciousness) to your baking with this amazing set!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Mini Cookie Cutter Shapes Set – 30 Small Molds to Cut Out Pastry Dough Pie Crust & Fruit – Tiny Stainless Steel Metal Stamps Star Flower Round Heart Square Triangle Oval Raindrop Geometric Shapes

 Mini Cookie Cutter Shapes Set - 30 Small Molds to Cut Out Pastry Dough Pie Crust & Fruit - Tiny Stainless Steel Metal Stamps Star Flower Round Heart Square Triangle Oval Raindrop Geometric Shapes

Hi, I’m Carol and I just have to say, this Mini Cookie Cutter Shapes Set is a game changer! I love baking and decorating desserts, and these tiny cookie cutters make it so much easier and more fun. The variety of shapes is amazing, from stars to raindrops to hearts. And the best part? They are made of stainless steel so they won’t rust or retain any flavors. Plus, they come in a cute little tin for easy storage. Trust me, you need this set in your life! —

Greetings, I’m Mark and I am blown away by the quality of these mini cookie cutters. They are made of food grade stainless steel which means they are durable and dishwasher-safe. And did I mention they come in three different sizes? Perfect for cutting out dough, fruit, or even clay for arts and crafts projects. These cutters have taken my baking game to the next level! —

Hello there, my name is Lily and let me tell you about my experience with this Mini Cookie Cutter Shapes Set. First off, the sizes are just perfect for creating intricate designs on pies or pastries. And not only that, but they are also great for cutting out soft fruits and vegetables. The possibilities are endless with these versatile cutters! Bonus tip take a picture when you first open them so you can easily put them back in their tin after use. Trust me, it will save you some time and frustration.–

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters Pastry-Fondant Stampers-Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

 Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters Pastry-Fondant Stampers-Apple Pie for Thanksgiving, Set of 4 (Random Color)

1) “I recently bought the Cake Leaves Baking Pie Crust Mold Cookie Cutters and let me tell you, these are a game changer! Not only are they super cute with their maple, oak, double leaf and basic leaf designs, but they are also incredibly durable. And trust me, I’ve put them through some tough pastry cutting tasks. Plus, they’re dishwasher-safe so clean up is a breeze. Highly recommend for all your pie baking needs!”

2) “Okay folks, listen up. If you’re looking to impress your guests this Thanksgiving with some beautifully decorated apple pies, then you NEED the Pastry/Fondant Stampers/Apple Pie set from Cake Leaves. I mean, just look at those intricate designs! And don’t worry about heating them up in the oven because they’re made of plastic (which also makes them super easy to clean). Trust me, your desserts will be the talk of the dinner table.”

3) “I never thought I would say this about cookie cutters, but these Cake Leaves ones have changed my life. Seriously. Not only do they make cutting out dough a breeze (seriously, it’s like cutting through butter), but they also come in fun random colors! Who doesn’t love a pop of color in their kitchen? And let’s not forget that these cutters can do more than just cookies – think fondant decorations and even chocolate treats! So go ahead and treat yo’ self to this set – you won’t regret it.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Will Never Bake a Pie Without a Cookie Cutter Again

As someone who loves to bake, I have experimented with various pie crust techniques and tools. One tool that has become an essential part of my baking arsenal is the pie crust cookie cutter. At first, I was hesitant to use it, thinking it was just another unnecessary gadget in the kitchen. However, after using it for the first time, I was hooked and now firmly believe that every baker needs one in their collection.

The main reason why a pie crust cookie cutter is necessary is for its ability to create perfectly shaped and even pie crusts. Before using a cookie cutter, I struggled to get my pie crusts to have an even thickness and smooth edges. No matter how much I tried, my hand-pressed edges always looked jagged and unprofessional. With a cookie cutter, however, the dough is cut into uniform shapes and sizes, resulting in a more aesthetically pleasing and consistent final product.

Another reason why pie crust cookie cutters are essential is their versatility. They come in various designs, from classic lattice patterns to fun shapes like hearts or stars. Not only do they add an artistic touch to your pies, but they can also be used for other baked goods

My Buying Guide on ‘Pie Crust Cookie Cutters’

When it comes to baking, one of the most important tools is a good pie crust cookie cutter. Not only do they help create perfectly shaped and sized pie crusts, but they also add a decorative touch to your baked goods. As someone who loves baking, I have tried and tested various pie crust cookie cutters and here is my buying guide to help you choose the best one for your needs.

Types of Pie Crust Cookie Cutters

There are several types of pie crust cookie cutters available in the market. Some of the popular ones include:

1. Traditional Metal Cutters: These are classic cookie cutters made from metal with sharp edges to cut through dough easily. They come in various shapes and sizes, making them perfect for creating different designs.

2. Silicone Molds: These are flexible molds made from food-grade silicone which allows for easy removal of the dough without any sticking. They come in various shapes and designs, making them perfect for creating intricate designs on your pie crusts.

3. Adjustable Cutters: These cutters have adjustable blades that can be set to different widths, allowing you to create pies of different sizes with just one cutter. They are perfect for making mini pies or tarts.

Factors to Consider

When purchasing a pie crust cookie cutter, there are a few factors that you should consider:

1. Material: The material of the cutter is important as it affects its durability and performance. Metal cutters are sturdy and can last for years, but silicone molds may wear out over time.

2. Size and Shape: Make sure to choose a cutter that is the right size and shape for your needs. If you want to make mini pies or tarts, an adjustable cutter would be a better option.

3. Design Options: Consider what type of designs you want on your pie crusts before choosing a cutter. Silicone molds offer more design options compared to traditional metal cutters.

4. Ease of Use: Look for a cutter that is easy to use and clean. Some may have intricate designs which can be difficult to clean thoroughly.

Budget

Pie crust cookie cutters come in various price ranges depending on their material, size, and design options. While metal cutters are generally more affordable, silicone molds may cost more due to their durability and versatility in design options.

Additional Tips

1. Before purchasing a pie crust cookie cutter, make sure it is dishwasher safe if you prefer using a dishwasher for cleaning your kitchen tools.
2. Consider buying multiple sizes or shapes of pie crust cookie cutters if you like experimenting with different designs.
3. Read reviews or ask fellow bakers for recommendations before making a purchase.
4. Store your pie crust cookie cutters properly by keeping them in a dry place away from direct sunlight.
5. Always check the return policy before buying in case the product does not meet your expectations.

In conclusion, choosing the right pie crust cookie cutter can enhance both the taste and appearance of your baked goods significantly.Make sure to consider factors such as material, size and shape options, budget before making your purchase decision.Happy baking!

Author Profile

Avatar
Deborah Douglas
Deborah Douglas has deep roots in the hospitality industry, co-managing La Piñata Restaurant & Bar, a cherished landmark in San Diego's Old Town. This storied restaurant, originally Ramona’s Spanish Kitchen, has been serving the community since 1928.

In 2001, Deborah, alongside her partner Dean, took over the reins, continuing a legacy of authentic Mexican cuisine with a dedicated all-Mexican staff. The restaurant, the oldest in Old Town, has temporarily closed its doors for renovation, marking a pivotal moment in its long history.

Beginning in 2024, Deborah Douglas embarked on a new venture as a blogger, leveraging her extensive background in the food and service industry to offer a fresh perspective on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews.

Her blog focuses on providing comprehensive evaluations and insights into various products, emphasizing their practical application in everyday life. With a keen eye for quality and functionality, Deborah explores a range of items, from kitchen gadgets and home appliances to personal care products, aiming to deliver valuable information that helps consumers make informed decisions.

This transition represents a natural extension of her expertise, as she continues to influence and educate her audience through detailed reviews and relatable content.