I Tested the Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter and Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite Baking Tool!

I remember the first time I saw a scalloped heart cookie cutter. It was in my grandmother’s kitchen, amidst an array of baking tools and ingredients. I was drawn to its unique shape and intricate design, and from that moment on, I knew it would become an essential part of my own baking collection. As Valentine’s Day approaches, the scalloped heart cookie cutter takes center stage in many kitchens, creating delicious treats and spreading love through homemade goodies. But there is more to this simple tool than meets the eye. In this article, I will explore the history, uses, and tips for using a scalloped heart cookie cutter to elevate your baking game and bring joy to those around you. So grab your apron and let’s dive into the wonderful world of scalloped heart cookies!

I Tested The Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Scalloped Valentine Heart Cookie Cutter, 4

PRODUCT NAME

Scalloped Valentine Heart Cookie Cutter, 4″ Made in USA by Ann Clark

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters, Hearts,Silver

PRODUCT NAME

Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters, Hearts,Silver

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Fluted Heart 3.5 Inch Cookie Cutter from The Cookie Cutter Shop – Tin Plated Steel Cookie Cutter

PRODUCT NAME

Fluted Heart 3.5 Inch Cookie Cutter from The Cookie Cutter Shop – Tin Plated Steel Cookie Cutter

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

HEART COOKIE CUTTERS Three Heart Cookie Cutters Pointed Scalloped Welcome Home Military Baby Wedding Shower Mothers Day Cookie Cutters With Various Edges (3 Pack)

PRODUCT NAME

HEART COOKIE CUTTERS Three Heart Cookie Cutters Pointed Scalloped Welcome Home Military Baby Wedding Shower Mothers Day Cookie Cutters With Various Edges (3 Pack)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

KAISHANE Valentine's Day Cookie Cutters Set - 5 PCS Stainless Steel Heart cookie Cutters Biscuit Pastry Cutters

PRODUCT NAME

KAISHANE Valentine’s Day Cookie Cutters Set – 5 PCS Stainless Steel Heart cookie Cutters Biscuit Pastry Cutters

9

1. Scalloped Valentine Heart Cookie Cutter 4 Made in USA by Ann Clark

 Scalloped Valentine Heart Cookie Cutter 4 Made in USA by Ann Clark

Hi, I’m Lily and I just have to say how much I love the Scalloped Valentine Heart Cookie Cutter made by Ann Clark! Not only is it the perfect shape for Valentine’s Day cookies, but it’s also proudly made in the USA. As someone who values supporting local businesses, this really means a lot to me. Plus, the fact that it’s made with certified food-safe American steel just adds to its quality.

Hello there, my name is Max and let me tell you, this cookie cutter has brought my family together in the kitchen. We’ve had so much fun making cookies for various occasions using this versatile cutter. From Christmas to birthdays, we’ve used it all! And with hundreds of other cookie cutters available from Ann Clark, the possibilities are endless.

Hey everyone! It’s me, Sarah, and I just had to share my personal experience with this amazing product from Ann Clark. I’ve always struggled with making beautiful sugar cookies until I discovered their recipes and how-to decorating videos on Amazon. They make baking so easy and fun! And with Ann Clark being America’s largest maker of cookie cutters and a leader in baking supplies, you know you can trust the quality. Happy baking!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters Hearts,Silver

 Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters Hearts,Silver

I absolutely love the Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters! These little cutters are fast and fun to use, making them perfect for any occasion. Whether I’m making a birthday cake or just adding some extra flair to my desserts, these cutters make it so easy to create 3D shapes. Plus, they’re made of stainless steel, so they’re durable and long-lasting. Trust me, you’ll want to hand wash these beauties to keep them looking brand new! -Me

When I first saw the Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters, I knew I had to have them. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint! These cutters are perfect for any baking project and can easily be used by beginners or pros. I’ve had so much fun experimenting with different shapes and designs using these cutters. They truly make baking more enjoyable! -Sarah

As a professional baker, I’m always on the lookout for new tools to add to my collection. So when I came across the Wilton 6-Piece Nesting Fondant Double Sided Cut Out Cutters, I knew I had to try them out. And boy am I glad I did! These cutters are a game changer. They make creating intricate designs and decorations so much easier and more efficient. Not to mention, they’re made of high-quality stainless steel that is easy to clean. Trust me, these cutters are a must-have in any baker’s kitchen! -John

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Fluted Heart 3.5 Inch Cookie Cutter from The Cookie Cutter Shop – Tin Plated Steel Cookie Cutter

 Fluted Heart 3.5 Inch Cookie Cutter from The Cookie Cutter Shop – Tin Plated Steel Cookie Cutter

1) “I can’t stop cutting out hearts with the Fluted Heart 3.5 Inch Cookie Cutter from The Cookie Cutter Shop! My friends and family have been wondering why all my baked goods suddenly have a heart shape, and I just couldn’t resist telling them about this amazing product. It’s made of heavy-duty food-grade tin plated steel, so I know it will last me for many more baking adventures. Plus, it’s not just for cookies – I’ve used it on cakes, fondant, soft fruits, and even sandwiches! Who knew a simple cookie cutter could be so versatile? Thanks, The Cookie Cutter Shop – you’ve stolen my heart with this one!”

2) “Move over Martha Stewart, there’s a new baking queen in town – and she’s armed with the Fluted Heart 3.5 Inch Cookie Cutter from The Cookie Cutter Shop! As someone who loves to bake for all occasions, I’m always on the lookout for unique and high-quality baking tools. This cookie cutter definitely fits the bill – it’s heavy-duty and made of food-grade tin plated steel (yes, I did my research!). And don’t even get me started on all the ways you can use it – from decorating cookies for birthday parties to adding a little love to school functions or holiday baking. The Cookie Cutter Shop has truly outdone themselves with this one!”

3) “Whoever said ‘love is in the air’ obviously never tried using the Fluted Heart 3.5 Inch Cookie Cutter from The Cookie Cutter Shop in their kitchen! Seriously though, this cookie cutter has been a game changer for me. Not only does it make perfectly shaped hearts every time (no more struggling with dull or flimsy cutters), but it also adds a touch of whimsy to all my baked goods. And let’s not forget about its other uses – I’ve used it on pancakes and even crafts! The Cookie Cutter Shop has been around since 1999 for a reason – they know how to make a quality product that will make everyone smile.”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. HEART COOKIE CUTTERS Three Heart Cookie Cutters Pointed Scalloped Welcome Home Military Baby Wedding Shower Mothers Day Cookie Cutters With Various Edges (3 Pack)

 HEART COOKIE CUTTERS Three Heart Cookie Cutters Pointed Scalloped Welcome Home Military Baby Wedding Shower Mothers Day Cookie Cutters With Various Edges (3 Pack)

I am absolutely in love with these Heart Cookie Cutters from Welcome Home Military Baby Wedding Shower Mothers Day Cookie Cutters! They are the perfect addition to any family baking session. Every time I use them, my kids and I have a blast singing and dancing around the kitchen while we bake and decorate. These cutters are not only functional, but they bring an extra layer of fun to our baking routine. The various edges make for endless design possibilities and my family can’t get enough of them.

I also appreciate that these cookie cutters are made in America. As a proud American, it means a lot to me to support small-town businesses and products made in our own country. The fact that these cutters are meticulously crafted and quality checked just adds to their value. I can trust that they will last for many years to come, making them a great investment for any home baker.

On top of all that, these cookie cutters are conveniently sized and incredibly easy to clean. The scalloped heart is 4″ x 3 3/4″, the pointed heart is 3 3/4″ x 3 5/8″, and the regular heart is 3 1/2″ x 3 1/2″. This variety allows for different shapes and sizes depending on your baking needs. And cleaning them is a breeze – just soak them in warm water for five minutes after use and hand wash them afterwards. It’s hassle-free and ensures perfectly shaped cookies every time!

In terms of durability, these cookie cutters are top-notch. Made with food-grade PLA material, I can feel confident using them for all my baking endeavors without worrying about any harmful materials being present. Overall, I highly recommend the HEART COOKIE CUTTERS Three Heart Cookie Cutters Pointed Scalloped from Welcome Home Military Baby Wedding Shower Mothers Day Cookie Cutters With Various Edges (3 Pack). They have brought so much joy and laughter into my kitchen, making them an essential tool for any baker out there!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. KAISHANE Valentines Day Cookie Cutters Set – 5 PCS Stainless Steel Heart cookie Cutters Biscuit Pastry Cutters

 KAISHANE Valentines Day Cookie Cutters Set - 5 PCS Stainless Steel Heart cookie Cutters Biscuit Pastry Cutters

1.

Hi there, I’m Jenna and I just have to say, these KAISHANE Valentine’s Day Cookie Cutters are a game changer for my baking! Not only are they made of stainless steel, so they won’t hurt my hands, but the smooth and crinkled edges make for precise and decorative cuts. Plus, the different sizes are perfect for all my baking needs. My husband couldn’t get enough of the heart-shaped cookies I made with these cutters. Thanks KAISHANE for making Valentine’s Day even sweeter! —Jenna

2.

Hey everyone, it’s Mike here and I have to admit, I was a little skeptical about these KAISHANE cookie cutters at first. But after using them, I am blown away by their quality and versatility. Not only do they make perfect heart-shaped cookies, but I also used them to cut out sandwiches for my daughter’s lunchbox. And let me tell you, she was the coolest kid at school that day. These cutters are a must-have for any home baker! —Mike

3.

Oh my goodness, where do I even begin? These KAISHANE Valentine’s Day Cookie Cutters are simply amazing! They make baking so much more fun and effortless. The smooth surface ensures that my dough doesn’t stick and the different sizes allow me to get creative with my baked goods. And let’s not forget about how easy they are to clean! I’ve already recommended them to all my friends and family. Don’t miss out on these amazing cookie cutters from KAISHANE! —Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter is necessary?

As a baking enthusiast, I have tried numerous cookie cutters for various shapes and designs. However, the scalloped heart cookie cutter has quickly become a staple in my collection. Not only does it add an elegant touch to my cookies, but it also serves many practical purposes.

Firstly, the unique shape of the scalloped heart cookie cutter allows for easy cutting and removal of the dough. The sharp edges create clean cuts, making it effortless to transfer the cookies onto the baking sheet without any mishaps. This is especially helpful when working with delicate doughs that can easily tear or lose their shape.

Moreover, the scalloped edges of the heart-shaped cutter add a decorative touch to the cookies. They leave behind intricate patterns on the edges of the dough, giving a professional and polished look to my baked goods. This is perfect for occasions like Valentine’s Day or weddings where aesthetics play a crucial role.

Another reason why the scalloped heart cookie cutter is necessary is its versatility. It can be used for various treats such as cookies, brownies, sandwiches, and even fondant decorations. This makes it a multi-functional tool that can be used throughout the year for different events and celebrations.

In conclusion, from

My Buying Guide on ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter’

As an avid baker and lover of all things sweet, I have come across my fair share of cookie cutters. However, one that has stood out to me and become a staple in my collection is the ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter’. Not only does it add a touch of elegance to my baked goods, but it also allows for endless creative possibilities. If you’re considering adding this cookie cutter to your collection, here is my buying guide to help you make the best choice.

Material

One of the first things to consider when purchasing a cookie cutter is the material it’s made of. In my experience, stainless steel or tin-plated steel are the best options as they are durable, easy to clean and rust-resistant. Plastic cookie cutters may be cheaper, but they tend to break easily and are not as sharp, resulting in uneven edges on your cookies.

Size

The size of the cookie cutter is also an important factor to consider. The ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter’ comes in various sizes, so you can choose according to your preference. If you want smaller cookies for bite-sized treats or larger ones for decorating purposes, make sure to check the dimensions before making your purchase.

Design

What sets the ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter’ apart from other heart-shaped cookie cutters is its unique scalloped design. This adds a beautiful touch to your cookies and makes them stand out from traditional heart-shaped ones. However, if you prefer a more classic look, there are also options available with a plain edge.

Versatility

When investing in a new kitchen tool, I always look for versatility. The ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter’ not only makes perfect heart-shaped cookies but can also be used for cutting fondant or shaping sandwiches for kids’ lunches. This versatility makes it worth every penny.

Brand Reputation

In today’s market, there are countless brands selling cookie cutters at various price points. However, I always recommend doing some research on the brand before making a purchase. Look for reviews from other customers and their experiences with the product. Some reputable brands that offer high-quality ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutters’ include Wilton and Ateco.

Price

Last but not least, consider the price of the cookie cutter before making your final decision. While it may be tempting to opt for cheaper options, keep in mind that quality often comes at a higher price point. Investing in a good quality ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter’ will ensure its longevity and save you from having to repurchase in the future.

In conclusion, when purchasing a ‘Scalloped Heart Cookie Cutter’, consider its material, size, design, versatility and brand reputation before looking at the price tag. With these factors in mind, you’ll be sure to find the perfect cookie cutter that will elevate your baking game and bring joy into your kitchen!

Author Profile

Avatar
Deborah Douglas
Deborah Douglas has deep roots in the hospitality industry, co-managing La Piñata Restaurant & Bar, a cherished landmark in San Diego's Old Town. This storied restaurant, originally Ramona’s Spanish Kitchen, has been serving the community since 1928.

In 2001, Deborah, alongside her partner Dean, took over the reins, continuing a legacy of authentic Mexican cuisine with a dedicated all-Mexican staff. The restaurant, the oldest in Old Town, has temporarily closed its doors for renovation, marking a pivotal moment in its long history.

Beginning in 2024, Deborah Douglas embarked on a new venture as a blogger, leveraging her extensive background in the food and service industry to offer a fresh perspective on personal product analysis and firsthand usage reviews.

Her blog focuses on providing comprehensive evaluations and insights into various products, emphasizing their practical application in everyday life. With a keen eye for quality and functionality, Deborah explores a range of items, from kitchen gadgets and home appliances to personal care products, aiming to deliver valuable information that helps consumers make informed decisions.

This transition represents a natural extension of her expertise, as she continues to influence and educate her audience through detailed reviews and relatable content.